If you're familiar with Bosmans' mature style, these compositions may surprise you. They have a lush, romantic sound to them. This is a dramatic contrast to the stripped-down harmonies she started using in the 1930s.
The Violin Sonata was written while Bosmans was studying with Jan Willem Kersbergen. It's full of youthful energy and enthusiasm.
My one criticism is that the piano part seems overly showy. Not out of character for a young piano virtuoso/composer. But at times it threatens the balance between the two instruments.
The Arietta is a very different piece. Though written within a year of the sonata, the Arietta is much more introspective. Plus, Bosmans reigns in the piano, letting the violin sing. Because of the range -- and the character -- of this music, the Arietta is often performed on the viola. Nice to hear the composer's original intent here.
The Piano Trio shows Bosmans' growth as a composer. The handling of her material is much more assured. The piano part is meaty, but never overpowers the other instruments. Also, this work seems more emotionally focused somehow.
The players of the Solarek Trio turn in some fine performances. To my ears, the recordings -- especially the sonata -- seemed a little boomy. Consider it a nit, but one I had to mention.
Henriëtte Bosmans is a major figure in Dutch music. But she's little known outside the Netherlands. Here's hoping this release will encourage more folks to explore her catalog. It's worth the effort.
Henriëtte Bosmans: Early Chamber Music
Solarek Piano Trio
Toccata Classics TTOCC 0654
“The players of the Solarek Trio turn in some fine performances” Really? These are unquestionably some of the most awful, amateurish performances of these works I could imagine. Dreadful intonation, particularly by the violinist, but overall a poor effort by all involved. The recorded sound is also abysmal. Of the well over 5000 recordings I’ve purchased over the last 30+ years, this ranks as perhaps the most disappointing. It’s unlistenable. It’s a shame, because this is music that deserves better. Maybe you were just being kind and generous in your assessment of this disc, I can’t really say, but basically all of the reviews I’ve come across of this disc had a much different take than yours. I’m not questioning your ability to recognize the poor quality of this product, just your ability to be honest about what you’re hearing.
ReplyDelete